Skip to main content

Table 3 Adherence to evidence-based practices, per pause point and overall, in facilities under study, over time, % (95% C.I)

From: Evaluation of Dakshata, a scale-up WHO SCC and mentoring-based program, for improving quality of intrapartum care in public sector in Rajasthan, India: repeated mixed-methods surveys

 

Group 1, N = 12 facilities

Group 2, N = 12 facilities

Bulk training ongoing

Mentoring ongoing

Need based mentoring ongoing

Mentoring completed

Need based mentoring ongoing

Need based mentoring for a year

Blood pressure measured (obs)

52 (30–74)

63 (45–81)

83 (78–89)

67 (51–83)

61 (27–94)

97 (95–99)

Foetal heart sounds assessed (obs)

70 (59–81)

80 (64–96)

84 (79–90)

82 (75–89)

85 (77–92)

96 (93–99)

PA examination (obs)

86 (78–93)

83 (67–99)

95 (90–100)

91 (86–97)

65 (40–89)

96 (93–99)

PV examination (obs)

93 (88–98)

100 (99–100)

97 (95–100)

99 (98–100)

97 (95–99)

100

Hand Hygiene in PV examination (obs)

16 (3–29)

31 (4–58)

73 (69–78)

49 (40–58)

30 (5–55)

90 (81–100)

Average Pause point 1

63 (53–73)

71 (61–82)

87 (83–90)

78 (73–82)

67 (52–83)

96 (94–98)

Pre-filled oxytocin (obs)

67 (51–83)

70 (55–85)

97 (95–99)

78 (71–86)

81 (72–91)

94 (87–100)

Ready bag and mask (obs)

85 (72–98)

94 (88–100)

70 (51–89)

97 (94–100)

88 (70–100)

92 (84–100)

Clean, dry and warm towels (obs)

47 (25–69)

67 (42–92)

76 (62–90)

74 (55–93)

65 (53–76)

82 (72–92)

Used clean cord cut (obs)

99 (98–100)

100

99 (98–100)

99 (98–100)

99 (97–100)

100

Oxytocin within 5 minutes (obs)

74 (63–85)

85 (77–94)

77 (64–89)

83 (78–87)

84 (77–91)

94 (91–97)

Average Pause point 2

74 (65–84)

83 (76–91)

84 (78–89)

86 (81–92)

83 (77–89)

92 (89–96)

Baby dried immediately (obs)

86 (74–98)

98 (96–100)

84 (73–95)

99 (97–100)

94 (89–99)

90 (80–99)

Baby weight observed (obs)

71 (59–82)

86 (75–97)

79 (68–90)

96 (93–100)

75 (64–86)

64 (44–83)

Breast feeding initiated within one hour (obs)

42 (12–73)

54 (30–77)

79 (69–89)

45 (30–59)

48 (35–61)

78 (69–88)

Assessed uterine tone (obs)

73 (63–84)

30 (14–46)

72 (61–83)

82 (72–93)

38 (16–59)

69 (50–89)

Mothers vitals checked (obs)

13 (2–24)

16 (4–27)

67 (56–77)

25 (7–44)

9 (2–17)

82 (67–97)

Average Pause point 3

57 (51–63)

57 (50–63)

76 (68–85)

69 (64–75)

53 (46–60)

76 (70–82)

Newborn immunised (cs)

10 (4–16)

27 (0–55)

31 (0–65)

56 (34–78)

56 (34–78)

42 (11–74)

Mother’s temperature measured (cs)

46 (23–69)

56 (18–94)

64 (42–87)

61 (39–84)

61 (39–84)

98 (95–100)

Counselled for any danger sign in newborn (int)

17 (11–24)

15 (0–34)

11 (7–15)

21 (9–33)

19 (8–30)

3 (1–6)

Counselled for any danger sign in mother (int)

18 (10–26)

10 (0–21)

21 (12–30)

27 (4–50)

8 (3–14)

35 (0–75)

Counselled for family planning (int)

30 (13–48)

60 (39–80)

71 (50–92)

57 (38–77)

20 (6–33)

74 (57–92)

Average Pause point 4

24 (18–30)

34 (27–40)

40 (32–47)

44 (32–57)

33 (28–37)

51 (45–57)

Overall Average

55 (51–59)

61 (55–68)

72 (69–75)

69 (64–75)

59 (53–65)

79 (75–82)

N = 4814

N = 4822

N = 4978

N = 4813

N = 4843

N = 4836

Stillbirth rate, per thousand live births (95% C.I.)

15 (6–15)

17 (10–23)

2 (0–5)

25 (9–40)

19 (14–23)

11 (8–14)

Caesarean rate, % (95% C.I.)

2.0 (0.2–3.8)

4.8 (0.0–9.7)

7.6 (1.4–13.9)

2.9 (0–5.7)

2.3 (0–4.8)

1.4 (0–3.9)

Mothers’ referral rate, % (95% C.I.)

0.1 (0.0–0.3)

0.7 (0.1–1.2)

0.1 (0.0–0.2)

0.4 (0.1–0.7)

0.5 (0.1–0.9)

0.2 (0.0–0.4)

Newborn referral rate, % (95% C.I.)

1.4 (0.0–2.8)

1.9 (0.8–3.0)

0.5 (0.0–1.2)

2.1 (1.0–3.2)

1.3 (0.6–2.0)

0.5 (0.0–1.5)

  1. *bold means significant p-value < 0.05 when compared to first assessment results, CS case sheets assessed after discharge, OBS direct observations, INT interviews conducted about a day after birth