Study | Group size (total N) | Adherence | Dropout rates post-intervention | Dropout rates at follow up | Satisfaction |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alasfour & Almarwani 2020 [25] | I: 20 C: 20 (40) | • An average of 85% of exercise sessions were completed | 10% | X | X |
Allen et al. 2018 [26] | I: 142 C: 68 (350) | • 80% logged on to program at least once • Mean of 21 logins per participant | 25% | 27% | X |
Allen et al. 2021 [27] | I: 230 C: 115 (345) | • 72% logged on to program at least once • Median of 2 logins per participant (median of 11 for those that logged in at least once) | 29% | X | X |
Bennell et al. 2017 [28] | I: 74 C: 74 (148) | • 68% of home exercise sessions completed • 78% accessed education material • 64% of PCST practices completed • Average of 6.4 of 8 PCST modules were completed | 5% | 11% | • Education = 1.8/5a • PCST = 2/5a • Physiotherapy = 1/5a |
Bennell et al. 2018 [31] | I: 73 C: 71 (144) | • 72% of home exercise sessions completed • 74% accessed educational material • Average of 6.6 of 8 PCST modules were completed | 9% | 12% | 17 questions on the usability of PCST. See paper for details. |
Bossen et al. 2013 [15] | I: 100 C: 99 (199) | • 94% logged on at least once • 62% of education modules completed • 46% adherent to the intervention (6/9 modules completed) • 19% completed all modules | 16% | 24% | SUS = 73/100a |
Gohir et al. 2021 [29] | I: 48 C: 57 (105) | • An average of 88% of exercise sessions were completed | 28% | X | X |
Kloek et al. 2018 [34] | I: 109 C: 99 (208) | • 81% of participants adhered to the program (completed at least 8 of the 12 modules) | 18% | 39% | SUS = 73/100a |
Nelligan et al. 2021 [30] | I: 103 C: 103 (206) | • 97% logged on at least once • 39% accessed the website in final 4 weeks • Mean of 6 logins per participant • 73% reply rate to text messages | 13% | X | • Treatment satisfaction = 5.6/7a • Usefulness of website = 5.3/7a • Usefulness of text messages = 5.3/7a |
Pelle et al. 2020 [32] | I: 214 C: 213 (427) | • 80% opened the app at least once • 70% adherent to intervention (chose at least one goal) • 53% achieved at least one goal • 26% still used intervention at the end of the study | 39% | X | SUS = 65/100a |
Rini et al. 2015 [33] | I: 58 C: 55 (113) | •91% completed all PCST modules | 2% | X | X |