Skip to main content

Table 3 Quality rating of the modeling studies based on three best practice recommendations from ISPOR

From: Optimal strategies for COVID-19 prevention from global evidence achieved through social distancing, stay at home, travel restriction and lockdown: a systematic review

Author and year Was the model a dynamic (transmission) model? Did the authors conduct uncertainty analyses on key assumptions that may have had an impact of the conclusions? Do the results provide estimates of the change in the burden of infection due to the intervention? Quality
Matteo 2020 [27] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Alexander 2020 [28] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
William 2020 [29] Yes No No Major concerns
Juanjuan 2020 [30] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Stephen 2020 [31] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Bendtsen 2020 [32] Yes No Yes Moderate concerns
Per Block 2020 [33] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Kiesha 2020 [34] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Neil 2020 [35] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Adam 2020 [36] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Deanna 2020 [37] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Biao 2020 [38] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Zifeng 2020 [39] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns
Laura 2020 [40] Yes Yes Yes No concerns to minor concerns